logo
Login Subscribe
Google Play App Store
  • News
    • Obituaries
    • Lifestyle
    • Opinions
  • Sports
  • E-edition
  • Public Notices
  • Calendar
  • Archives
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • Advertisers
    • Form Submission
    • About Us
    • News
      • Obituaries
      • Lifestyle
      • Opinions
    • Sports
    • E-edition
    • Public Notices
    • Calendar
    • Archives
    • Contact
      • Contact Us
      • Advertisers
      • Form Submission
      • About Us
Harms family still seeking answers
news
January 31, 2024
Harms family still seeking answers
By LaDonna Rhodes Staff Writer,

Amanda “Mandi” Harms was laid to rest Wednesday, January 24, at Greenlawn Cemetery in Checotah, but her family says that they won’t rest until they know what really happened to her.

Just before Mandi’s Homegoing Celebration at Lighthouse Christian Center in Eufaula, her family held a press conference in which they stated that after viewing her body they don’t know how foul play could be ruled out and they had more questions for Muskogee Police Department.

Mandi’s husband, Erik Harms, stated that they received little communication from Muskogee PD leading up to the day that Mandi was discovered dead in a backyard over three miles away from her home. In fact, Muskogee PD had only come by that very day and told the family that Amanda had been seen on video and she had made it as far as 40th and Broadway. Then less than an hour later, they returned to say that she had been found deceased and they just wanted to let the family know before it was on social media. When the family looked, the Muskogee Police Department had already posted on their social media that she was found deceased and that officers were investi-Erik gating the scene. It had been five days since Mandi had walked away from her home in Muskogee in freezing temperatures. Her mother, Shelley Townsend, had filed a missing person’s report the following day after Erik had contacted her to ask if she had heard from Mandi because she hadn’t returned home.

“Originally when this all started, we felt like the investigation was moving at a slow pace,” Erik said. “However, we had the benefit of a doubt that investigators were moving forward and doing what needed to be done. When we were notified that she was found deceased on Thursday, Jan. 18, we weren’t given any information of how it happened or what had occurred.”

Erik stated that during the time of her disappearance he had turned off his social media and hadn’t been watching any news but decided to look at an article to find out what police were saying about the case.

“I saw that the police made a statement that no foul play was involved. So we requested a meeting with the investigators at Muskogee Police Department to give us details of what had actually happened, where she was found, and all the information from this. So both Shelley and I met with them on Friday, the 19th and they went through the steps of their investigation and what they found.”

Through those steps what should have calmed their nerves only made them question everything more. Why had the police told them that Amanda was seen at 40th and Broadway but they didn’t tell them that she had flagged down a vehicle and gotten into the vehicle? Why weren’t they told that police had found some of her clothing on Tuesday at a stranger’s house?

“They said they received a tip on Tuesday the 16th,” Erik said. “And that Mandi had left her coat, hat and gloves in a house that didn’t have any heat,” Erik said. “The investigator made a comment that when he stepped in there on Tuesday that it was pretty much the same temperature inside as it was outside. So when he picked up the hat, coat and gloves, I asked him did they search the house or take any other evidence that Mandi was actually at that house and they said no. And then they came back and said that getting a warrant may be tough…Then the lead investigator said remember at this time it was just a missing person and no crime had been committed. So even though Mandi had been missing for three days it was not enough to ask for permission to search the house.”

Mandi’s husband went on to state that apparently Mandi had run out of the house where she had been and she appeared to be frantic as she ran across the street to another house and began knocking on the door. The people heard the knock on the door but did not answer; then she went running to the back yard, dropping her sock and her boot which were found several feet away from where she was found days later with some of her clothing caught in the fence.

“Because they said no signs of foul play, we were going to wait on the medical examiner’s report to conclude the cause of death but we were told that the medical examiner’s report has to wait on the toxicology report which could take four months or even possibly longer,” Erik said. “And they do not release any information to us and we’ve also been told that they don’t release any information to the police until this is completed.”

“The reason this is so urgent is because we finally got to see her for the first time and there are definite signs of trauma. She had a cut, split eyelid; her upper lip was completely split, and bruising all throughout her face. Her nose was broken and we don’t know for sure, but her orbital bone around her eye socket could have been broken and there were definitely cuts, scrapes all along her hands and other signs of trauma that we won’t get into. I just don’t know how the investigators could say there are no signs of foul play. As a family we definitely feel like this needs to be investigated more.”

Mandi’s mom stated that they wouldn’t let this go until they have more answers and she hopes the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigations will look into the case.

“We just want the truth,” Townsend cried. “As a mother I couldn’t even bear to look at my daughter in the condition that she was left in and I can’t imagine the last few hours of her life and what she went through.”

After the family’s statements and concerns appeared on television, the Muskogee Police Department issued a press release the following day, Jan.24, stating that they had received a preliminary report via phone call from the Medical Examiner’s Office in reference to Amanda Harms’ case and that the following information was obtained from that conversation.

• No lethal trauma

• No sexual assault trauma

• Abrasions and scratches on her face and extremities that were consistent with where and how her body was located

• Hypothermia cannot be ruled out as a cause of death

• No foul play is suspected • The initial toxicology report detected no elicit substances other than alcohol and benzodiazepines in her system. (Detected NOT confirmed.) These results will not be confirmed until the toxicology report comes back from the lab.

The release went on to state that these were the initial findings but that the official Medical Examiner’s report and cause of death are still pending.

Let there be light!
A: Main, news
Let there be light!
By Shauna Belyeu General Manager 
November 26, 2025
Downtown Eufaula came alive Friday night as the community gathered for the annual Lights on Eufaula celebration, officially ushering in the Christmas season with bright lights, festive music, and home...
Local Flavor draws a packed crowd
A: Main, news
Local Flavor draws a packed crowd
By MICHAEL BARNES 
November 26, 2025
Sandbar Tavern was filled to capacity on Tuesday, Nov. 18 as supporters from across the county gathered for an evening of food, fellowship, and hometown generosity, all in support of Under One Roof, t...
Checotah resident sentenced for distributing Methamphetamine
A: Main, news
Checotah resident sentenced for distributing Methamphetamine
November 26, 2025
MUSKOGEE, OKLAHOMA – The United States Attorney’s Office for the Eastern District of Oklahoma announced that Andrew Frank Lerblance, a/k/a Andrew Frank Lerblance, Jr., age 66, of Checotah, Oklahoma, w...
First advisory committee held to help shape Eufaula’s future growth
A: Main, news
First advisory committee held to help shape Eufaula’s future growth
By Shauna Belyeu General Manager 
November 26, 2025
The City of Eufaula is in the process of creating a comprehensive plan along with the help of Freese and Nichols, a privately owned engineering, planning and consulting firm serving clients across the...
Candidate filing begins for Board of Education
A: Main, news
Candidate filing begins for Board of Education
November 26, 2025
Candidate filing for the Board of Education begins Monday, Dec. 1, 2025, for McIntosh County school districts. Those who wish to file for a Board of Education office must submit a Declaration of Candi...
Lake Eufaula Association Announces First-Ever Christmas Tour of Homes
A: Main, news
Lake Eufaula Association Announces First-Ever Christmas Tour of Homes
November 26, 2025
The Lake Eufaula Association is thrilled to announce our 1st Annual Christmas Tour of Homes, happening Thursday, December 11th from 4:30 PM to 8:00 PM. This brand-new holiday event celebrates the beau...
ePaper
google_play
app_store
Editor Picks
Voices of gratitude: What I’m thankful for
news
Voices of gratitude: What I’m thankful for
November 26, 2025
“I am thankful for the love and support of his family and friends, health and the opportunities for my future. I wish everyone a safe and happy holiday.” - Eufaula senior, Luke Hodgens “I’m grateful f...
Native Holiday Arts and Crafts show Dec. 6
news
Native Holiday Arts and Crafts show Dec. 6
November 26, 2025
The Eufaula-Canadian Tribal Town will host a Native Holiday Arts and Crafts show on Saturday, Dec. 6th, at the Eufaula Indian Community Center, 800 Birkes Road, Eufaula, from 9:00am-3pm. Various handm...
It pays to shop Eufaula
news
It pays to shop Eufaula
By Shauna Belyeu General Manager 
November 26, 2025
Holiday cheer is officially in full swing, and Eufaula is ready to jingle all the way! Vision Eufaula has unwrapped this year’s Shop Eufaula campaign, turning the town into a festive trail of prizes, ...
A Thanksgiving message to our community
news
A Thanksgiving message to our community
By Shauna Belyeu General Manager 
November 26, 2025
As we head into Thanksgiving, we find ourselves reflecting on what makes our community so special. This isn’t just about where we live; it’s all the simple moments that remind us that small-town life ...
Grateful this season
commentary, lifestyle, Opinions
Grateful this season
November 26, 2025
It seems like time is flying by and months are changing within days not weeks as year after year pass too quickly. However, I know every season has something that we can be grateful for if we just loo...
Facebook

THE EUFAULA INDIAN JOURNAL
100 N. 2nd Street
Eufaula, OK 74432

(918) 689-2191

This site complies with ADA requirements

© 2023 THE EUFAULA INDIAN JOURNAL

  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Accessibility Policy