logo
Login Subscribe
Google Play App Store
  • News
    • Obituaries
    • Lifestyle
    • Opinions
  • Sports
  • E-edition
  • Calendar
  • Archives
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • Advertisers
    • Form Submission
    • About Us
    • News
      • Obituaries
      • Lifestyle
      • Opinions
    • Sports
    • E-edition
    • Calendar
    • Archives
    • Contact
      • Contact Us
      • Advertisers
      • Form Submission
      • About Us
Pardoning Proves Power of Presidency
commentary
February 19, 2025
Pardoning Proves Power of Presidency

December 2024 and January 2025 may possibly go down in history as one of the most politically significant moments in recent history. In December then-President Joe Biden broke a record by issuing pardons or commuted sentences of more than 1,500 people. Several of his pardons were preemptive ones for family members and other politicians. Biden’s most controversial pardon was for his son Hunter, which Biden promised during the campaign that he would not do.

Then, in December alone, Biden signed 13 executive orders on his way out of office. Once President Trump was inaugurated, Trump pardoned around 1,500 people who were involved in the Jan. 6 riots and signed more than 45 executive orders.

Personally, I question the constitutionality of many of these executive orders; many of these should fall under the authority of Congress. I also have ethical questions about Biden’s pardons. As for the Trump ones, I do agree with some but do feel that the leaders and those who were violent or destructive should be punished for their actions.

The difference between the executive orders and the pardons are that the former are constitutionally questionable while the latter, while I disagree with many of them, all fall within the scope of the president’s rights.

Even more, historically speaking, Trump pardoning those accused of insurrection were not the first a president has done so. You may be surprised to see who the first president was.

First, as always, the Constitution. Article II, Section 2, Clause 1 reads, “The President… shall have Power to grant Reprieves and Pardons for Offences against the United States, except in Cases of Impeachment.”

As I have discussed several times in this column, the Constitution can be extremely vague, and this clause has raised countless questions over the years. One question that was never answered during Trump’s first term was if self-pardoning was allowed.

The Supreme Court never made a ruling on that situation as Trump did not try it. However, for many other scenarios the Court has ruled with the 1866 Ex parte Garland case probably being the most important.

In that case, Congress had passed a law that forbade any member of the Confederate government to hold a court position.

Augustus Hill Garland of Arkansas fit into that category but had been pardoned by President Andrew Johnson, so Garland sued on grounds that the law should not apply to him. The Court agreed with a 5-4 decision that stated, “The [pardon] power… extends to every offence known to the law and may be exercised at any time after its commission, either before legal proceedings are taken or during their pendency or after conviction and judgment.”

Other than state crimes, civil cases, and impeachment, Ex parte Garland basically gives the president unchecked pardoning power. Not only can the president pardon someone for a crime before they are tried, like Gerald Ford did for Richard Nixon, but they can pardon anyone for a crime they committed that no one even knows about — like Biden possibly did for his family.

It should be noted that presidents cannot prepardon for a crime; the act must have been committed before the blanket pardon is issued. However, the pardoning power is so strong that presidents can even pardon someone for the most serious crime in the Constitution: treason. In fact, the first president to do so was none other than George Washington.

The ones that most remind me of the Jan. 6 pardons were those of the Whiskey Rebellion.

The rebellion came about from a decision of America’s favorite rapper, Alexander Hamilton, who had been put in charge of the Treasury Department and was tasked with getting America out of the debt incurred from the Revolutionary War. Hamilton issued what became known as Reports on Public Credit, which, among many topics, said the way the government would earn money was though tariffs, selling of public lands in the west, and a tax on whiskey (really any distilled alcohol).

There are two schools of thought about the tax. One is that Hamilton had no idea the hubbub he would create. The other — and I lean this way — is that he knew exactly what would happen.

One of the reasons the Constitution was even created was that under the previous government, the Articles of Confederation, were not strong enough to stop Shays’ Rebellion. These scholars believed Hamilton, trying to show the strength of new government, hoped the tax would lead to an uprising so that he could crush it and show there was a new sheriff in town. The Broadway play forgets to talk about this story.

Whatever the thought process was, the tax did lead to problems on the western frontier, which at this point in time were areas like western Pennsylvania. Small farmers there were hit hard as it was easier for them to turn their grains into alcohol and ship east rather than ship wagons full of raw grain.

Larger farms also were affected by this, but they could handle it. Many of these small yeoman farmers had learned as soldiers in the Revolutionary War that when the government became tyrannical, they had the right to fight back. And fight back they did. At first, the farmers just refused to pay the tax. But in 1794 when they were pressed, they attacked tax collectors and burned down the home of one of them in Pittsburg.

With this, Hamilton convinced Washington to call out the militia, and for the only time in American history, the president rode at the head of the army to Pennsylvania to squash the rebellion.

Washington did not travel the entire distance. By the time the militia arrived the rebellion had broken up. Of the 150 men the militia arrested for treason, two were convicted. Yet after the trial, Washington pardoned everyone involved, even the ones not arrested, calling them “misled.” Washington wanted to show his subjects that the government had the power to enforce its laws yet could also show mercy.

While the pardons of the Jan. 6 rioters and the Whiskey Rebellion were both done for political reasons, they don’t seem to be the same. It’s difficult to call the Biden family pardons political as much as family preservation.

It seems odd to give the president this much power, but Hamilton argued it was the right thing to do. In Federalist No. 74 he said, “It is not to be doubted, that a single man of prudence and good sense is better fitted, in delicate conjunctures, to balance the motives which may plead for and against the remission of the punishment, than any numerous body whatever.”

So, while we all just witnessed what I see in some ways as a reach in presidential powers, at least with the pardons what they did is completely Constitutional.

James Finck is a professor of American history at the University of Science and Arts of Oklahoma. He can be reached at HistoricallySpeaking1776@ gmail.com.

Whole Hawg Days on the horizon
A: Main, news
Whole Hawg Days on the horizon
July 16, 2025
Get ready for another fun-filled weekend as the 41st Annual Whole Hawg Arts & Crafts Festival prepares to get underway, Friday and Saturday, July 25-26. The festival will consist of Arts & Crafts, a r...
A: Main, news
Eufaula Chamber of Commerce Rodeo debuts
July 16, 2025
The rodeo is woven into the fabric of Eufaula history. Long before the annual rodeo was held at the fairgrounds, there were rodeos in an area of the city now a part of the cove where there are softbal...
A: Main, news
Check with the City before starting work
July 16, 2025
As more residents and property owners take on home improvement projects, the City of Eufaula is reminding the public of a key first step: check with the City before you begin. Whether you   are buildi...
Eufaula hires full-time fire chief
A: Main, news
Eufaula hires full-time fire chief
By JERRY FINK MANAGING EDITOR 
July 16, 2025
Eufaula didn’t have to look far for its first full-time fire chief. Checotah Fire Chief Greg Carmack has been offered the job, replacing volunteer Fire Chief Chad French. The decision to hire someone ...
Checotah says goodbye to cowboy legend Bill Duvall
A: Main, news
Checotah says goodbye to cowboy legend Bill Duvall
By LaDonna Rhodes Staff Writer 
July 16, 2025
When Bill Duvall was called to meet His Maker in the Great Round Up in the sky this past Sunday, Checotah lost one of its best storytellers and legendary cowboys ever. Thankfully his legacy will live ...
A: Main, news
Hats off to those credited with keeping the roundup club and rodeo alive
By Current Chamber of Commerce Board of Directors 
July 16, 2025
Serena Kleveter, director Jay Hunn, president Zach McQuay Roxanne Loyd Kathy Turner Jeanette Smith Torie Anderson Peter Lee 1940-50 Doc Thurman Doc Gawf Dub Hammett 1960-70 Glen Pittman Fred Wendel Ho...
ePaper
google_play
app_store
Editor Picks
A: Main, news
Commissioners pass moratorium
July 16, 2025
TransAlta of Canada announced six months ago that it no longer planned to develop a wind turbine farm in McIntosh County. However, county commissioners wanted to make sure TransAlta or any other wind ...
news
Auditions for The Dancing Princesses open to all
July 16, 2025
If you’ve ever thought acting on stage might be fun, here’s your chance to find out. The Eufaula Performing and Arts Club is opening auditions for their next play to any would-be actor ages 10 and up....
news
McIntosh County GOP News
By LYNELLE MEDLEY CHAIRMAN 
July 16, 2025
Our potluck at the last meeting was so much fun and we had a fabulous turnout -- thank you to all of McIntosh County for supporting the Republican Party. We hope you enjoyed it as much as we did. It w...
news
Man facing obscenity charges
July 16, 2025
Ryan Troy Dick, 52-year-old Sallisaw resident, is being held in the McIntosh County Jail pending his preliminary hearing on charges related to indecent photographs and videos sent to a former girlfrie...
news
Juvenile dies following accident near Longtown
July 16, 2025
The Oklahoma Highway Patrol reports that a juvenile, whose name and age are being withheld, was fatally injured in a single-vehicle accident that took place at about 10:30 p.m. on July 4. The deceased...
Facebook

THE EUFAULA INDIAN JOURNAL
100 N. 2nd Street
Eufaula, OK 74432

(918) 689-2191

This site complies with ADA requirements

© 2023 THE EUFAULA INDIAN JOURNAL

  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Accessibility Policy