logo
Login Subscribe
Google Play App Store
  • News
    • Obituaries
    • Lifestyle
    • Opinions
  • Sports
  • E-edition
  • Calendar
  • Archives
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • Advertisers
    • Form Submission
    • About Us
    • News
      • Obituaries
      • Lifestyle
      • Opinions
    • Sports
    • E-edition
    • Calendar
    • Archives
    • Contact
      • Contact Us
      • Advertisers
      • Form Submission
      • About Us
Scrutinizing primaries: Political history is cyclical, evolutionary
commentary
October 9, 2024
Scrutinizing primaries: Political history is cyclical, evolutionary
By ? r. James Finck, USAG History Professor

————— current events through a historical lens————————

I read something online the other day that said, “not to brag but I have won as many primary votes as Kamala Harris.” At first it made me chuckle, but then it made me think.

My first thought was “how many times has a candidate run for president without winning a single state in the primary?” Then I remembered that we did not even hold primaries until the 20th century, so the answer is a lot. In fact, historically speaking, we did not actually start really using primaries the way we think of them today until the 1972 election.

For the first several elections after George Washington stepped down, the Federalists and Jeffersonian Republican party leaders met in caucuses to decide who would run; the people had absolutely no say in the nomination. The first election where a party used a convention to nominate a candidate occurred in 1831 by the short lived Anti-Masonic Party. The party formed out of deep distrust and power of the Freemasons.

Wanting more transparency in government, the Anti-Masons highlighted the corruption of such a small few choosing presidential nominees and opened their convention to delegates from each state to cast a public vote. While the Anti-Masonic Party did not win any electoral votes, by calling out the other parties as elitists and undemocratic, they forced the other parties to change their nomination system from small caucuses to conventions.

Although parties had begun utilizing conventions to choose candidates, it wasn’t a mass wave of democracy. Each state chose delegates to represent them at a national convention, but those delegates were still made up of party insiders who could control the outcome as they were free to choose any candidate they saw fit.

The delegates were often chosen at closed or secret party meetings and held at random times of the year without informing rank-and-file party members.

The Progressive Era of the late 19th to early 20th centuries brought another change. In an attempt to bring more democracy to government, Progressives lobbied for the direct election of senators but also for primary elections to choose presidential nominees.

It took some time for the practice to start, but 13 states held primaries in 1912. The primaries held little importance as William Howard Taft lost to Teddy Roosevelt but still won the Republican nomination at the convention. The primary held little sway. Even with the primary’s growth, it mattered little to eventual nominees. In 1920, Republican nominee Warren G. Harding did not even enter the primary race yet won the nomination and the presidency. Republican Herbert Hoover did not win the primary in 1932 but still became the nominee only to be trounced by Franklin Delano Roosevelt — same with Alf Landon in 1936 and Wendell Willkie in 1940.

Three more elections saw the same trend as Republican Thomas Dewey in 1948 and Democrat Adlai Stevenson in 1952.

All lost their primary but still won the nomination.

Finally, the system came to a head in 1968 in the election that keeps being referenced because of its similarity with our current election. In ’68, incumbent President Lyndon B.

Johnson saw the writing on the wall and backed out of the election while Eugene McCarthy and Bobby Kennedy racked up primary wins. With Kennedy’s death and McCarthy halting his campaign, LBJ’s vice president, Hurbert Humphrey, joined the race and was able to win at the convention without winning a single primary. This was a difficult convention for the Democrats as the anger inside the convention was overshadowed by the violence outside.

Held in Chicago, mobs clashed with police in the streets. Protestors inside and out were angered that their voices did not matter, and party leaders were able to choose the next candidate with no input — a situation not unlike this year’s Democratic Convention. It was a bad look for the party.

So after Humphrey lost to Nixon in the general election, the Democratic Party decided to make some changes before the next election.

The changes came in the form of the McGovern- Fraser Commission, headed by Senator George McGovern and Representative Donald M. Fraser. The commission’s suggestions were to adopt a primary and caucus system in all states and required dele-gates to vote for the winner. All primaries and caucus elections needed to be transparent and open to normal voters. Delegates would now be proportional based on votes received, and not winner-take-all.

It put in a diversity requirement to guarantee groups like minorities, women and young people were represented. Finally, it limited the number of party leaders who could serve as delegates (most are now superdelegates today). Starting with the 1972 election, the nomination process was turned into a democratic event where ordinary people now had a say on who their party would run for president. Well, at least until this year.

A key here is that these are party rules and not laws. Parties — Republicans adopted similar rules — are private and can make whatever rules they see fit. What we saw this year was a party rule change under these circumstances. While it seems undemocratic, it’s in no way illegal.

Since the McGovern-Fraser Commission, almost all states now have primaries. There are about 10 states that hold caucuses instead.

Primaries must follow state election rules, but caucuses do not. They tend to have much lower turnout, and the vote is public so that limits some from voting for more fringe candidates.

The caucus seems to be the last holdout for more party control while still allowing for some democracy.

In the end, it’s true that Kamala Harris has not won a single primary. While it has been some time since the last candidate has done the same, historically speaking, that has been more the rule than the exception before modern times.

On a complete side note, it has been suggested to me that some readers might enjoy some type of gathering to discuss history, like a dinner or a small conference. It could be casual conversation or a formal evening with talks. If you are interested, please send an email to historicallyspeakingl776@ gmail.

com.

James Finck is a professor of American history at the University of Science and Arts of Oklahoma. He can be reached at HistoricallySpeakingl 776@gmail. com.

Braving the festival, honoring a friend
A: Main, news
Braving the festival, honoring a friend
By LENORE BECHTEL 
September 3, 2025
Every Labor Day weekend since moving to Oklahoma, I thought about going to the Dusk to Dawn Blues Festival. But the idea of a yard party running from 5 p.m. to 5 a.m. was intimidating—and I could neve...
A: Main, news
Man injured diving into shallow water
September 3, 2025
A 22-year-old Yukon man was injured when he dove from a pontoon boat into shallow water at Lake Eufaula, according to the Oklahoma Highway Patrol. Patrick Tanner reportedly stopped his vessel to swim ...
A: Main, news
Man found dead in yard; possible suspect investigated
September 3, 2025
WARNER – Warner Police responded to a call early Saturday morning about a dead man laying outside of a residence in the area of Fifth and Third streets. The deceased has been identified as 51-year-old...
A: Main, news
Wellness Day for seniors Sept. 16
September 3, 2025
Heritage Home Care’s fifth annual Senior Wellness Day will be held Tuesday, Sept. 16, from 9 a.m. to 2 p.m. at 126 N. 1st St. (now Bridges Street), which is the former location of Family Dollar. The e...
A: Main, news
Looking ahead: Firm to help guide the way
By JERRY FINK MANAGING EDITOR 
September 3, 2025
What will Eufaula look like in 50 years? Without a plan, it’s anybody’s guess. But the City Council has taken steps to remove at least some of the guesswork. At a special meeting Friday, Aug. 29, the ...
Wine and Art Festival extravaganza Saturday
A: Main, news
Wine and Art Festival extravaganza Saturday
By JERRY FINK MANAGING EDITOR 
September 3, 2025
What: Vision Eufaula Wine & Art Festival When: Saturday Sept. 6, 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. Where: 150 N. Front St. Information: 405-248-2992 or visit visioneufaula.org The fourth annual Wine and Art Festival ...
ePaper
google_play
app_store
Editor Picks
5 in race for state school superintendent
news
5 in race for state school superintendent
By Jennifer Palmer Oklahoma Watch 
September 3, 2025
So far, five candidates are running to lead Oklahoma’s public education system as state superintendent in 2026. Former Tulsa school board members Jennettie Marshall, a Democrat, and Jerry Griffin, an ...
DOC Director stepping down
news
DOC Director stepping down
By KEATON ROSS OKLAHOMA WATCH 
September 3, 2025
Oklahoma Department of Corrections Director Steven Harpe, one of the highest paid officials in state government, will step down on Sept. 30 to take a private sector job. “I’m extremely proud of my tim...
news
Class of ’65 reunion set for Sept. 12
September 3, 2025
Graduates of the Eufaula High School Class of 1965 will get together from 2 p.m. to 4 p.m. on Friday, Sept 12, at the Legacy on Main Street, 224 N. Main St. Graduates of the classes of ’64 and ’66 are...
A site out of this world
news
A site out of this world
By MIKE BARNES 
September 3, 2025
In Eufaula, a town where gossip can outpace the mail, a story is slowly gaining momentum. It isn’t about the latest fishing tournament or Friday night football, but about a cosmic visitor called 3I/ A...
Rest, reflections, and farewells
commentary
Rest, reflections, and farewells
By JOE DORMAN OICA CEO 
September 3, 2025
OKLAHOMA CITY – I hope your Labor Day weekend was full of relaxation. I schedule a vacation each year with friends to get away over this holiday which allows me to “charge up the batteries” for upcomi...
Facebook

THE EUFAULA INDIAN JOURNAL
100 N. 2nd Street
Eufaula, OK 74432

(918) 689-2191

This site complies with ADA requirements

© 2023 THE EUFAULA INDIAN JOURNAL

  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Accessibility Policy