logo
Login Subscribe
Google Play App Store
  • News
    • Obituaries
    • Lifestyle
    • Opinions
  • Sports
  • E-edition
  • Calendar
  • Archives
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • Advertisers
    • Form Submission
    • About Us
    • News
      • Obituaries
      • Lifestyle
      • Opinions
    • Sports
    • E-edition
    • Calendar
    • Archives
    • Contact
      • Contact Us
      • Advertisers
      • Form Submission
      • About Us
Prevailing Winds: Switching Political Parties over Candidate Support
commentary
April 10, 2024
Prevailing Winds: Switching Political Parties over Candidate Support

In a recent CNN interview, Alaska Sen. Lisa Murkowski hinted that she is considering leaving the Republican Party. Murkowski has been a long-time opponent of former President Donald Trump and is struggling with the idea of Trump leading her party. Murkowski is not the first to leave the party over a personality, and historically speaking, switching parties has even brought great reward.

Murkowski, who was an avid Nikki Haley supporter, claims she is not the only Republican frustrated with the GOP’s direction in supporting a controversial candidate like Trump, but she is not considering joining the Democratic Party either. She is just as frustrated with Biden as she is with Trump, so she is considering becoming an independent.

It should not be surprising that another president, Andrew Jackson, who had a large yet antagonizing personality, also caused dissatisfaction. Anyone who reads this column knows that one of the presidents I most compared to Trump was Jackson. Trump himself has drawn comparisons and showed his admiration of Jackson when he hung his portrait in the Oval Office. Like Trump, Jackson could rub people wrong, which was the case of John Tyler of Virginia.

Tyler entered politics in 1816 as a representative to Congress and part of the Jeffersonian Republican Party. Like his fellow Virginians, he was a strong supporter of states’ rights and believed in a strict interpretation of the Constitution. In the short time that America had a one-party system (1816-1828) Tyler had become concerned with President John Quincy Adams’ nationalist policies and began supporting the Jackson wing of the party who called themselves Democratic Republicans. When Jackson broke from the Republicans, now calling himself simply a Democrat, he ran against Adams and won in 1828 with Tyler as a loyal supporter.

While Tyler had always supported the Republican/ Democrats, he started to find himself at odds with Jackson. While Jackson claimed he supported small government, his beliefs only seemed to apply to Congress and the courts. When it came to the power of the president, Jackson was seemingly doing more to strengthen the power of that office. During his term Jackson vetoed more bills than all the previous presidents combined and completely ignored the Supreme Court’s ruling when it came to Indian Removal. Yet what put Tyler over the top was the Nullification Crisis of 1833.

Back in 1828, before Adams left office, he signed into law a high tariff that became known as the Tariff of Abominations by Southerners. Adams’ vice president, John C. Calhoun, led the attack against the tariff but only went so far knowing that when Jackson took office, he would rectify the problem. However, to Calhoun’s surprise, now Jackson’s vice president, Jackson kept the tariff to gain Northern support. In a huff, Calhoun returned to South Carolina and led the state to officially nullify the tariff in their state.

Jackson’s response was to call up the army and march on South Carolina, almost igniting a civil war 30 years before the actual Civil War. With Jackson’s actions, Tyler left the Democratic Party to join with a new party founded to fight against Jackson known as the Whigs.

Jumping ahead to 1840, the Whig Party was looking for a first win, so they stole the Democrats’ handbook and ran a military hero from Ohio, William Henry Harrison, the hero of the Battle of Tippecanoe.

To appease the Southern wing of the party, round out the ticket, and possibly appeal to some Democrats, the Whigs put Tyler on the ticket as V.P. It also led to a nifty jingle, “Tippecanoe and Tyler, Too.” With their catchy jingle the Whigs won the presidency only to lose. Harrison gave an incredibly long inauguration address in the cold, caught pneumonia, and died 31 days later. Suddenly instead of a Whig president, they had Whig in name only, but one who still supported the ideas of states’ rights. Tyler spent his time as president fighting more with his own party than he did the Democrats, vetoing several bills passed by Whigs.

Because the Constitution did not say the vice president would become president, only exercise the power, many cabinet members felt they should have the true power and wanted Tyler to clear all decisions with them. Tyler rejected this idea, claiming he was the president now and would not address or open mail from anyone who referred to him as acting president or anything similar. In the end, his entire cabinet resigned. Tyler became a man without a party and was despised by both sides.

My favorite Tyler story is that in his last month of office he held a grand celebration in the White House where he came out on the balcony and announced, “they cannot say now that I am a president without a party.” Kind of a dropthe-mic moment.

It is unsure what will happen with Murkowski. She has not given any reason to think she would ever become a Democrat. But in a world of polarization, someone like her who could unite and pull from both sides of the aisle might look tempting for a party looking for a V.P.

James Finck is a professor of history at the University of Science and Arts of Oklahoma. He can be reached at HistoricallySpeakingl 776@gmail.com.

news
Give Back Day featuring 2 new services
June 18, 2025
The monthly Give Back Day, held the fourth Tuesdays at Under One Roof, will feature a couple of new professionals this month. On June 24, joining the Health Department’s visit will be Jacob Guinan, fr...
news
Friendship Kitchen Celebrates 12th Anniversary
June 18, 2025
In June 2013, the vision of serving nutritious meals in a welcoming atmosphere of friendship and spiritual acceptance became a reality in the Eufaula Lake community. On opening day, thirteen guests we...
commentary
Why does God love us?
June 18, 2025
One thing for certain God does not love us because of our goodness or because we are worthy of it. The prophet Jeremiah accurately described us in Jeremiah 17:9,”The heart is deceitful and desperately...
Spirit of farm themed VBS radiated in LECC’s sanctuary Sunday
news
Spirit of farm themed VBS radiated in LECC’s sanctuary Sunday
June 18, 2025
Vacation Bible School at Lake Eufaula Christian Church concluded with many rip-roaring “Yee-Haws” as children demonstrated how they felt after two days of learning about God’s greatest gift. When Asso...
Golden Eagle Poker Run makes a splash despite stormy weather
news
Golden Eagle Poker Run makes a splash despite stormy weather
June 18, 2025
Rain or shine—nothing could stop the 2025 Golden Eagle Poker Run from being one of the most exciting and memorable events on Lake Eufaula! Despite a surprise storm that soaked participants and volunte...
Book Review: Skousen’s ‘The Big Three in Economics’
commentary
Book Review: Skousen’s ‘The Big Three in Economics’
June 18, 2025
To better understand economic thought, I decided to tackle Mark Skousen’s 2007 book “The Big Three in Economics: Adam Smith, Karl Marx and John Maynard Keynes.” Not written as an economics textbook bu...
United for Oklahoma
ePaper
google_play
app_store
Editor Picks
news
County sales tax income up from last year
June 18, 2025
The Oklahoma Tax Commission recently released city sales tax collection figures that primarily represents local tax receipts from April business. The monies they reported this period represent sales f...
news
CASA for Children announces upcoming volunteer training in July
June 18, 2025
Muskogee - Every child in foster care deserves someone in their corner. This summer, you can be that someone. CASA for Children is offering a new volunteer training class beginning this July. The trai...
Community Calendar
news
Community Calendar
June 18, 2025
If you would like to list your meeting or event in the Community Calendar, please email all the information to jerry@cookson.news, call the Indian Journal at 918-689-2191 or drop the information off a...
Oklahoma democrat seeks DNC Vice Chair after overturned election
news
Oklahoma democrat seeks DNC Vice Chair after overturned election
By BLAKE MADDEN GAYLORD NEWS 
June 18, 2025
WASHINGTON— Kalyn Free — a Native American attorney and longtime Oklahoma Democrat — is running again for DNC vice chair, hoping to reshape the party’s focus on rural and Indigenous communities follow...
news
Cole seeks to protect Indian Health Service from budget cuts
By KYLIE CALDWELL GAYLORD NEWS 
June 18, 2025
WASHINGTON – U.S. Rep. Tom Cole (R, Moore), an enrolled member of the Chickasaw Nation, has spent 22 years in Congress fighting to protect tribal funding and says he won’t allow cuts to the Indian Hea...
Facebook

THE EUFAULA INDIAN JOURNAL
100 N. 2nd Street
Eufaula, OK 74432

(918) 689-2191

This site complies with ADA requirements

© 2023 THE EUFAULA INDIAN JOURNAL

  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Accessibility Policy